Transforming Research Assessment: Why CoARA Principles Matter for Every Researcher
Moving beyond citations to recognize the full value of research contributions
The Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment (CoARA) represents over 700 research organisations worldwide committed to reforming outdated assessment methods that rely heavily on publication-based metrics like citation counts. The coalition operates through 10 core commitments that guide systematic reform while respecting institutional autonomy.
CoARA@SFU: In October 2024, the SFU signed the Agreement on Reforming Research Assessment.
https://www.sfu.ac.at/de/news/sfu-joins-coara
https://www.sfu.ac.at/en/news/sfu-joins-coara
Led by Vice Dean Research Ass.Prof. Dr. Nora Ruck, along with a faculty-wide CoARA working group, the Faculty of Psychology is piloting the research assessment reform to account for the faculty’s diverse research cultures. The reform focuses on participatory engagement, qualitative indicators, and peer review. Through “participatory contact zones", a CoARAverse working group is reforming three assessment instruments at the individual and the faculty level: the Research Report, the Development Interview, and the External Research Evaluation. After the pilot phase, CoARAverse research assessment practices will be extended from the faculty to the university level.
https://psychologie.sfu.ac.at/de/news/forschungsevaluierung-coaraverse/
https://psychologie.sfu.ac.at/en/news/research-evaluation-coaraverse/
Why is reform necessary? Groundbreaking teaching innovations, crucial data management work, community engagement, mentoring excellence, and interdisciplinary collaborations frequently go unrecognized in systems focused primarily on journal impact factors and citation numbers. CoARA's vision centers on comprehensive assessment that recognizes diverse outputs and activities, basing evaluation primarily on qualitative judgment with peer review at its core. Factors beyond quantitative metrics should be considered; whether a researcher is developing innovative methodologies, engaging with policymakers, contributing to open science practices, or supporting early-career researchers, these valuable activities should receive appropriate recognition.
Why should you care? Research excellence encompasses far more than publication counts, and evaluation systems should reflect that reality. Understanding CoARA principles helps researchers better articulate their full contributions and supports institutions in developing more effective evaluation criteria.
Learn more: Visit coara.eu to explore the full agreement and see how this global movement is reshaping research assessment for the better.